Supreme Court Gives Judges Flexibility In Mandatory Minimum Cases

By
Bill Weinberg

The US Supreme Court on April 4 handed down a unanimous decision in Dean v. United States, giving federal judges greater flexibility in mandatory minimum cases—an aim activists have long been demanding. Advocacy group Families Against Mandatory Minimums filed a brief in support of the petitioner in the case.

As Bloomberg BNA reports, Levon Dean Jr, of Sioux City, faced consecutive mandatory minimum sentences for use of a firearm in two robberies of local drug dealers. The two mandatory sentences added up to 30 years: a five-year minimum for the first offense and a 25-year minimum for the second. Because of the severity of the mandatory firearm term, Dean requested a sentence of just one day on his robbery and conspiracy charges. The district court wrote that 30 years plus one day was “more than sufficient,” but nonetheless believed it lacked the authority to bend the mandatory minimum law. The Supreme Court has now found otherwise, and Dean will be getting his 30 years plus one day.

Chief Justice John G. Roberts wrote for the high court: “The bar on imposing concurrent sentences does not affect a court’s discretion to consider a mandatory minimum when calculating each individual sentence.”

Of course, although drugs were involved in Dean’s case, the mandatory minimum in question actually concerned firearms—a notorious sacred cow for the political right. But this sets a precedent that may apply in mandatory-minimum cases concerning drugs as well.

Bill Weinberg

Bill Weinberg is based in New York City.

By
Bill Weinberg

Recent Posts

Intentional Medicine

Sun Roots Farm puts nature in charge.

2 hours ago

The Gift of Flavor

Chef Maverick creates feel-good sauces and snacks that cater to dietary restrictions.

1 day ago

Louisiana Legislative Committee Unanimously Passes Adult-Use Cannabis Framework Bill

If signed into law, the Louisiana bill would establish a regulatory framework for recreational cannabis,…

2 days ago

Study Reveals State Cannabis Legalization Lowers Immigrant Deportation

There's just a false sense of security related to the federal government to worry about.

2 days ago

Vegans Rejoice as Farmers Switch from Chickens to Hemp

A trend is emerging among poultry farmers who are converting operations to industrial hemp farms.

2 days ago

Weed Made Me Less Angry. Now It Sometimes Makes Me Mad.

I was once angry. But weed helped. Then, weed kinda made me angry again.

2 days ago